The Dukedom of Braunschweig-Lüneburg and the Dating of Fagrskinna
The paper deals with the problem of dating of Fagrskinna in the context of
literary production on Iceland in the 12th and 13th centuries and especially of the
sagas about the Norwegian Kings. The dating and the original writing-context
of different sagas and saga compilations are of course of great importance
for analysing not only the source value in relation to the history they describe,
but also for understanding how the texts represent different positions within
the society they were written for. In the following paper a rather recent effort
to re-date the saga compilations Fagrskinna and Heimskringla will be taken into
consideration. Fagrskinna was written around 1225, and since Heimskringla made
use of Fagrskinna, at least in its later parts, it must have been written somewhat
later, suggestively from the middle of the 1220s to the beginning of 1230s.
References
Ágrip af Nóregs konunga sǫgum / Hrsg. Finnur Jónsson (Altnordische Saga-
Bibliothek, 18). Halle (Saale), 1928.
Ahrens K.-H., Patze H. Die Begründung des Herzogtums Braunschweig im Jahre
1235 und die “Braunschweigische Reimchronik” // Ausgewählte Aufsätze
von H. Patze / Hrsg. P. Johanek et al. Stuttgart, 2002. P. 587–608.
Andersson Th.M. The Partisan Muse in the Early Icelandic sagas (1200–1250).
Ithaca; N.Y., 2012.
Andersson Th.M. The Sagas of Norwegian Kings 1130–1265. An Introduction.
Ithaca, N.Y., 2016.
Bagge Sverre. Society and Politics in Snorri Sturluson’s Heimskringla. Berkeley,
1991.
Bjarni Aðalbjarnarson. Om de norske kongers sagaer. Oslo, 1937.
Bjarni Einarsson ’Formali’// Ágrip af Nóregskonunga sǫgum; Fagrskinna –
Nóregs konunga tal / Bjarni Einarsson gáf út. Reykjavík, 1985. Bls. V–
CXXXI. (ÍF, XXIX)
Brandi K. Die Urkunde Friedrichs II vom August 1235 für Otto von Lüneburg //
Festschrift für P. Zimmermann. Wolfenbüttel, 1914. S. 33–46.
Constitutiones et acta publica imperatorum et regum / Ed. L. Weiland (MGH LL
IV / 2). Hannover, 1896. T. II.
Ehlers J. Heinrich der Löwe: Eine Biographie. München, 2008.
Fagrskinna / Udg. Finnur Jónsson (Samfund til udgivelse af gammel nordisk
litteratur. B. XXX). København, 1902–1903.
Fenske L. Magnus Billung // Neue Deutsche Biographie. 1987. No. 15. S. 666– 667.
von Heinemann L. Heinrich von Braunschweig: Pfalzgraf bei Rhein: Ein Beitrag
zur Geschichte des staufischen Zeitalters. Gotha, 1882.
10 Based on Gustav Storm 1875, Gustav Indrebø suggested that Fagrskinna was written after
‘around 1225’ but before 1230, suggestively at the end of the 1220s (Indrebø 1917.
P. 271–275). Bjarni Aðalbjarnarson 1937. P. 179, argued that Storm’s conclusion actually
demanded an earlier dating, and found the early 1220s more probable. Alfred Jakobsen
(1970. P. 113 with note 34 and P. 114 note 36) followed Bjarni Aðalbjarnarson. Both interpretations
are pressing the argument, and a date around 1225 would fit more smoothly with
the sum of the evidence. Cf. for example Bagge 1991. P. 19 and Andersson 2016. P. 65.
11 The question of the authorship of Heimskringla is however without complications, see
for example the discussion in Louis-Jensen 2013.
109
Indrebø G. Fagrskinna. Avhandlinger fra universitetets historiske seminar 4. Kristiania,
1917.
Jakobsen A. Om Fagrskinna-forfatteren // Arkiv för nordisk filologi. 1970.
B. 85. S. 88–124.
Janson H. Kring Austrfararvisur och Friðgerðarsaga // Sagas and the
Norwegian Experience: Tenth International Saga Conference. Trondheim
1997. Trondheim, 1997. P. 293–302.
Janson H. Templum nobilissimum: Adam av Bremen, Uppsalatemplet och
konfliktlinjerna i Europa kring år 1075. Göteborg, 1998.
Louis-Jensen J. Dating the Archetype: Eyrbyggja saga and Egils saga Skallagrímssonar
// Dating the Sagas: Reviews and Revisions / Ed. E. Mundal and
Theodore Andersson. Copenhagen, 2013. P. 133–147.
Lönnroth L. The Baptist and the Saint: Odd Snorrason’s View of the Two King
Olavs // International Scandinavian and Medieval Studies in Memory of
G.W. Weber / Ed. M. Dallapiazza. Trieste, 2000. P. 257–264.
Morkinskinna / Udg. Finnur Jónsson (Samfund til udgivelse af gammel nordisk
litteratur. B. LIII). København, 1928–1932.
Ólafía Einarsdóttir. Fagrskinnas forfattelsestidspunkt. Olaf Haraldsson – Tyskland
– Håkon Håkonsson // Germanisches Altertum und christlisches Mittelalter.
Festschrift für Heinz Klingenberg zum 65. Geburtstag / Hrsg. B. Brogyanyi
et al. Hamburg, 2002. S. 51–89.
Olafs saga hins helga: efter pergamenthaandskrift i Uppsala universitetsbibliotek,
Delagardieske samling nr. 8 II / Udg. O.A. Johnsen. Kristiania, 1922.
Origines Guelfica. Vol. IV / Udg. G.W. Leibniz et al. Hanover, 1753.
Regesta imperii. IV: Ältere Staufer. 3(1): Die Regesten des Kaiserreiches unter
Heinrich VI. 1165 (1190)–1197 / Ed. J. F. Böhmer and revised by G. Baaken,
Köln; Wien, 1972.
Saxo Grammaticus. Gesta Danorum: Danmarkshistorien. København, 2005. Vol.
I–II.
Schneidmüller B. Burg – Stadt – Vaterland: Braunschweig und die Welfen im
hohen Mittelalter // Heinrich der Löwe: Herrschaft und Repräsentation /
Hrsg. J. Fried und O-G. Oexle. Stuttgart, 2003. P. 27–81. (Vorträge und Forschungen,
57).
Storm G. Om indskuddene i Fagrskinna // Forhandlinger i Videnskabs-selskabet
i Christiania Aar 1875. Christiania, 1876. P. 81–108.
Theodoricus Monachus. Theodrici monachi Historia de antiquitate regum Norwagiensium
// Monumenta Historica Norwegiæ: Latinske kildeskrifter til
Norges historie i middelalderen udgivne efter offentlig foranstaltning / Udg.
G. Storm Kristiania, 1880. P. 1–68.
Werthschulte L. Heinrich der Löwe in Geschichte und Sage. Heidelberg, 2007.