The Byzantine Emperor as an Arbiter in the Conflicts of Monks, Both among Themselves and with Church Authorities
Institute of World History of the Russian Academy of Sciences
For citation: Vankova, Anna B. The Byzantine Emperor as an Arbiter in the Conflicts of Monks, Both among Themselves and with Church Authorities // Drevneishie gosudarstva Vostochnoi Evropy (The Earliest States of Eastern Europe). 2025: Ways and Means of Conflict Resolution / Editor of the volume Т.N. Jackson. Мoscow: GAUGN-Press, 2025. S. 1–1.
DOI: 10.32608/1560-1382-2025-46-1-1
Abstract: The article deals with the question of the legitimacy of the emperor’s intervention into disputes between monks and those of monks with church authorities. Three such cases have been chosen. The early Byzantine time is characterized by a conflict over Alexander Akoimetos, abbot from Syria. The conflict was resolved after the intervention of Empress Pulcheria. In the Middle Byzantine time, the arbiter in the monastic distribution was basileus John Tzimiskes, who resolved the disagreement between Athanasius of Athos and Athonite Kelliotoi on the acceptable way of life on Athos. For the late Byzantine time, the case of confrontation between Gregory Palamas and Barlaam of Calabria over the admissibility of isychast prayer practices and certain theological issues was taken. Emperor Andronicus III acted as the umpire there. What were the opinions of such behavior of the emperor? The emperor and the Church were assistants in the spiritual salvation of the subjects of the empire. However, the Church as a corporation and the Christians as subjects of the empire had to obey the emperor who had key administrative powers on many issues, including the convening of councils and the fight against heresies. Emperor Justinian, also a saint, had a new word in the relationship between the emperor and the Church. He declares the principle of “symphonia” of the priesthood and the kingdom. It was these principles that gave legitimacy to the intervention of the emperor into inter-monastic and inter-church disputes.
References
Александрова Т.Л. Пульхерия // ПЭ. 2020. Т. 59. С. 21–24. [Aleksandrova T.L. Pul’kheriya (Pulcheria) // Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya. 2020. Т. 59. S. 21–24.]
Асмус В., прот. Бернацкий М.М. Григорий Палама // ПЭ. 2006. Т. 13. С. 12–41. [Asmus V., prot. Bernatskiy M.M. Grigoriy Palama (Gregory Palamas) // Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya. 2006. Т. 13. S. 12–41.]
Ванькова А.Б. Ипатий // ПЭ. 2011. Т. 26. С. 160–162. [Vankova A.B. Ipatiy (Hypatios) // Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya. 2011. Т. 26. S. 160–162.]
Виноградов А.Ю. Александр Константинопольский // ПЭ. 2000. Т. 1. С. 526. [Vinogradov A.Yu. Aleksandr Konstantinopol’skiy (Alexander Akoimetos) // Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya. 2000. Т. 1. S. 526.]
Григорий Палама. Триады в защиту священно-безмолствующих / Пер., послесл., и комментарии В. Вениаминова. М., 1995. [Grigoriy Palama. Triady v zashchitu svyashchenno-bezmolstvuyushchikh (Gregory Palamas. Triads For the Defense of Those Who Practice Sacred Quietude). Moscow, 1995.]
[Евсевий Памфил.] Слово василевсу Константину по случаю тридцатилетия его царствования // Сочинения Евсевия Памфила, переведенные с греческого при Санкт-Петербургской духовной академии. СПб., 1852. Т. 2. С. 343–440. [Evseviy Pamfil. Slovo vasilevsu Konstantinu po sluchayu tridtsatiletiya ego tsarstvovaniya (Eusebius Pamphilius. Oration in Praise of Constantine) // Sochineniya Evseviya Pamfila, perevedennye s grecheskogo pri Sankt-Peterburgskoy dukhovnoy akademii. St. Petersburg, 1852. Т. 2. S. 343–440.] (а)
[Евсевий Памфил.] Четыре книги о жизни блаженного василевса Константина // Сочинения Евсевия Памфила, переведенные с греческого при Санкт-Петербургской духовной академии. СПб., 1852. Т. 2. С. 51–285. [Evseviy Pamfil. Chetyre knigi o zhizni blazhennogo vasilevsa Konstantina (Eusebius Pamphilius. Life of Constantine) // Sochineniya Evseviya Pamfila, perevedennye s grecheskogo pri Sankt-Peterburgskoy dukhovnoy akademii. St. Petersburg, 1852. Т. 2. S. 51–285.] (б)
Император // ПЭ. 2009. Т. 22. С. 93–406. [Imperator (Emperor) // Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya. 2009. T. 22. S. 393–406.]
Красиков С.В. Варлаам Калабрийский // ПЭ. 2003. Т. 6. С. 626–631. [Krasikov S.V. Varlaam Kalabriyskiy (Barlaam of Calabria) // Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya. 2003. Т. 6. S. 626–631.
Максимович К.А. Церковь в христианской империи (313–843 гг.) // История древней Церкви / Под общ. ред. К.А. Максимовича. М., 2012. Ч. 1: 33–843 гг. С. 192–233. [Maksimovich K.A. Tserkov’ v khristianskoy imperii (313–843 gg.) (Church in the Christian Empire, 313–843) // Istoriya drevney Tserkvi. Мoscow, 2012. Ch. 1: 33–843 gg. S. 192–233.]
Мейендорф И., протопр. Жизнь и труды свт. Григория Паламы. Введение в изучение. Изд. 2-е, исправленное и дополненное / Пер. Г.Н. Начинкина; под ред. И.П. Медведева, В.М. Лурье. СПб, 1997. [Meyyendorf I., protopr. Zhizn’ i trudy svt. Grigoriya Palamy. Vvedeniye v izucheniye (Introduction à l’étude de Grégoire Palamas). St. Petersburg, 1997.]
Никифор Григора. История ромеев / Пер. с греч. Р.В. Яшунского. СПб., 2013. Т. 1. [Nikifor Grigora. Istoriya romeyev (Nicephorus Gregoras. Roman History). St. Petersburg, 2013.]
Острогорский Г. История Византийского государства / Пер. с нем. М.В. Грацианского. М., 2011. [Ostrogorskiy G. Istoriya Vizantiyskogo gosudarstva (Geschichte des byzantinischen Staates). Moscow, 2011].
Тамаркина И.В. Афон // ПЭ. 2002 Т. 4. С. 103–122. [Tamarkina I.V. Afon (Athos) // Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya. 2002. T. 4. S. 103–122.]
Филофей Коккин, свт. Житие свт. Григория Паламы (Похвальное слово) / Пер. иерм. Антония. Переизд. Свято-Троицкая Сергиева Лавра, 2005. [Svt. Filofey Kokkin. Zhitiye svt. Grigoriya Palamy (Pokhval’noye slovo) (Life of st. Gregory Palamas). St. Trinity Laura, 2005.]
Actes du Prôtaton / Édition diplomatique par D. Papachryssanthou. P., 1975.
Beck H.-G. Kirche und theologische Literatur in Byzantinischen Reich. München, 1959.
Beck H.-G. Das byzantinische Jahrtausend. München, 1978.
Callinici Vita Hypatii. Leipzig, 1895.
Callinicos. Vie d’Hypatios / Introd., texte crit., trad. et notes par G.J.M. Bartelink. P., 1971.
Dagron G. Les moines et la ville. Le monaschisme à Constantinopole jusqu’au concile de Chalcédoine (451) // Travaux et mémoires. 1970. Vol. 4. P. 229–276.
Demetracopoulos J.A. Barlaam of Calabria // Encyclopedia of Medieval Philosophy / Ed. H. Lagerlund. Heidelberg, L., N.Y., 2011.
Eusebius Caesariensis. Werke. Über das Leben Constantins; Constantins Rede an die Heilige Versammlung Tricennatsrede an Constantin / Hrsg. I. A. Heikel. Leipzig., 1902. Vol. 1.
Gregorae Nicephori Historiae Byzantinae / Ed. L. Schopen, I. Bekker. Bonnae, 1829. Т. 1.
Hatlie P. The Monks and Monasteries of Constantinople, ca. 350–850. Cambridge, 2007.
Hussey J.M. Orthodox Church in the Byzantine Empire. Oxford, 2010.
Ioannis Cantacuzeni Historiarum Libri IV / Cura L. Schopeni. Bonnae, 1828. Vol. I.
Mitsiou E. The Patriarchate and Imperial Power // A Companion to the Patriarchate of Constantinopole / Ed. by Ch. Gastgeber, E. Mitsiou, J. Preiser-Kapeller, Vr. Zervan. Leiden, 2021. P. 204–226.
Novellae Iustiniani // Corpus iuris civilis / Ed. Schoellii et Kroll. B., 1869–1939. Vol. 3.
Pargoire J. Rufinianes // Byzantinische Zeitschrift. 1899. Bd. 8. S. 429–477.
Rigo A. Gregorio Palamas. Tomo aghioritico. La storia, il testo e la dottrina. Leuven. 2021.
Russell N. Gregory Palamas and the Making of Palamism in the Modern Age. Oxford, 2019.
Sinkewicz R.E. Gregory Palamas // La théologie byzantine et sa tradition. Turnhout, 2002. T. 2. Р. 131–138.
Sokrates. Kirchengeschichte / Hrsg. von G.Ch. Hansen. B., 1995
Typikon de Tzimiskès // Actes du Prôtaton / Édition diplomatique par D. Papachryssanthou. P., 1975. P. 209–215.
Vie d’Alexandre l’Acémète / Per de Е. Stoop // Patrologia Orientalis. 1911. T. 6. Fasc. 5. Col. 645–657, 658–702.
La Vita di Atanasio l’Athonita di Atanasio di Panaghiou (Vita A) / Par Luigi d’Ayala Valva. Roma, 2017.
Γρηγορίου τοῦ Παλαμᾶ. Ὑπὲρ ἡσυχαζόντων. II. 1.1 // Λόγοι ἀποδεικτικοί, Ἀντεπιγραφαί, Ἐπιστολαὶ πρὸς Βαρλαὰμ καὶ Ἀκίνδυνον, Ὑπὲρ ἡσυχαζόντων // Γρηγορίου τοῦ Παλαμᾶ. Συγγράμματα T. Α΄-Ε΄ / Εκδ. Π.Κ. Χρήστου. Τ. Αʹ / ἐκδδ. B. Bobrinsky, Π. Παπαευαγγέλου, J. Meyendorff, Π.К. Χρήστου. Θεσσαλονίκη, 1988. [Grigoriy Palama. Triady v zashchitu svyashchenno-bezmolstvuyushchikh (Gregory Palamas. Triads For the Defense of Those Who Practice Sacred Quietude). Thessalonika, 1988.]
Φιλοθέου Κοκκίνου Λόγος εἰς ἅγιον Γρηγόριον Παλαμᾶν // Φιλοθέου Κοκκίνου Αγιολόγικα ἔργα. Α / καθ’ Δημητρίου Γ. Τσάμης. Θεσσαλονίκη, 1985. [Svt. Filofey Kokkin. Slovo o svt. Grigorii Palamy (Life of St. Gregory Palamas). Thessalonika, 1985.]