Why Don’t the Croats Want to Fight against Other Nations? On the Interpretation of the Accounts by Constantine Porphyrogenitus on the Treaty of the Croats with the Pope (DAI, ch. 31)
St.-Petersburg State University
For citation: Alimov, Denis E. Why Don’t the Croats Want to Fight against Other Nations? On the Interpretation of the Accounts by Constantine Porphyrogenitus on the Treaty of the Croats with the Pope (DAI, ch. 31) // Drevneishie gosudarstva Vostochnoi Evropy (The Earliest States of Eastern Europe). 2025: Ways and Means of Conflict Resolution / Editor of the volume Т.N. Jackson. Мoscow: GAUGN-Press, 2025. S. 1–1.
DOI: 10.32608/1560-1382-2025-46-1-1
Abstract: The article examines the accounts about the treaty between the Croats and the Pope from ch. 31 of the mid-10th century treatise “De administrando imperio” by the Byzantine emperor Constantine Porphyrogenitus. Contrary to the traditional opinion according to which the accounts reflect some real contacts between the Croats and Rome in the 7th century or during the reign of the Croat dux Branimir (879–c. 892), the author substantiates the hypothesis according to which the idea of an oath given by the Croats to the Pope promising not to fight against other peoples, and of a prayer received from the Pope which ensured the Croats the intercession of St. Peter in case they were being attacked, arose in the context of the formation of the Croat gentile kingdom (regnum Chroatorum) in the territory of Frankish Dalmatia in the second third of the 9th century. The emergence of the idea of a special relationship between the Croats and Rome is considered by the author as a result of communication between the Franks and the Croats that ensured a mutually acceptable legitimization of a new status of the Croat elite in the political and ideological space of the Carolingian realm for which special relations with Rome and the patronage of St. Peter were of fundamental importance.
References
Алимов Д.Е. «Переселение» и «крещение»: к проблеме формирования хорватской этничности в Далмации // SSBP. 2008. № 2 (4). С. 94–116. [Alimov D.E. «Pereselenie» i «kreshchenie»: k probleme formirovaniya khorvatskoy etnichnosti v Dalmatsii («Migration» and «Conversion»: On the Problem of the Formation of the Croat Ethnicity in Dalmatia) // SSBP. 2008. No. 2 (4). S. 94–116.]
Алимов Д.Е. Этногенез хорватов: Формирование хорватской этнополитической общности в VII–IX вв. СПб., 2016. [Alimov D.E. Etnogenez khorvatov: Formirovaniye khorvatskoy etnopoliticheskoy obshchnosti v VII–IX vv. (Ethnogenesis of the Croats: the Formation of the Croat Ethnopolitical Community in the 7th–9th Centuries). St. Petersburg, 2016.]
Алимов Д.Е. Известия Константина Багрянородного о крещении сербов и хорватов в правление императора Ираклия (610–641): проблема интерпретации // Христианское чтение. 2018. № 4. С. 214–224. [Alimov D.E. Isvestiya Konstantina Bagryanorodnogo o kreshchenii serbov i khorvatov v pravlenie imperatora Irakliya (610–641): problema interpretatsii (Constantine Porhyrogenitus’s Accounts of the Conversion of the Serbs and Croats under Emperor Heraclius (610–641): a Problem of Interpretation) // Khristianskoe chteniye. 2018. No. 4. S. 214–224.]
Коматина П. Константин Порфирогенит и рана историjа Jужних Словена. Београд, 2021. [Komatina P. Konstantin Porfirogenit i rana istorija Južnih Slovena (Constantine Porphyrogenitus and the Early History of the South Slavs). Belgrade, 2021.]
Константин Багрянородный. Об управлении империей / Под ред. Г.Г. Литаврина, А.П. Новосельцева; пер. Г.Г. Литаврина. 2-е изд. М., 1991. [Konstantin Bagryanorodnyy. Ob upravlenii imperiyey (Constantine Porphyrogenitus. On the Governance of the Empire) / Ed. G.G. Litavrin, A.P. Novosel’tsev; transl. by G.G. Litavrin. 2nd ed. Moscow, 1991.]
Хроники Фредегара / Пер. с лат., комм., вступ. статья Г.А. Шмидта. СПб., 2017 [Khroniki Fredegara (Chronicles of Fredegar) / Transl., Сommentaries and Introductory Article by G.A. Shmidt. St. Petersburg, 2017.]
Alimov D. Hrvati, kult Peruna i slavenski gentilizam (Komentari na hipotezu Ante Miloševića o identitetu Porina i Peruna) // SHP. Ser. III. 2016. Sv. 43. S. 141–164.
Ančić M. Ranosrednjovjekovni Neretvani ili Humljani: Tragom zabune koju je prouzročilo djelo De administrando imperio // Hum i Hercegovina kroz povijest. Zbornik radova s međunarodnoga znanstvenog skupa održanog u Mostaru 5. i 6. studenog 2009. Knj. I / Ur. I. Lučić. Zagreb, 2011. S. 217–278.
Annales Mettenses Priores (Scriptores rerum Germanicarum in usum scholarum ex Monumentis Germaniae historicis separatim editi). Hannoverae; Lipsiae, 1905.
Annales Regni Francorum et Annales qui dicuntur Einhardi / Rec. F. Kurze. Hannoverae, 1895.
Budak N. Tumačenje podrijetla Hrvata i najstarije povijesti Hrvata u djelima srednjovjekovnih pisaca // Etnogeneza Hrvata / Ur. N. Budak. Zagreb, 1995. S. 73–78.
Caspar E. Pippin und die Römische Kirche: Kritische Untersuchungen zum Fränkisch-Päpstlichen Bunde im VIII. Jahrhundert. B.; Heidelberg, 1914.
Chrysos E. The Empire, the Gentes and the Regna // Regna and Gentes: The Relationship between Late Antique and Early Medieval Peoples and Kingdoms in the Transformation of the Roman World / Ed. by H.-W. Goetz, J. Jarnut and W. Pohl; with the Collaboration of S. Kaschke. Leiden; Boston, 2003. P. 13–19.
Dabinović A. Državnopravni odnos Hrvata prema istočnom carstvu // Rad Hrvatske akademije znanosti i umjetnosti. 1941. Knj. 270. S. 49–148.
Daly W.M. St. Peter: An Architect of the Carolingian Empire // Studies in Medieval Culture (Kalamazoo, Mich.). 1973. Vol. IV. P. 55–69.
Dzino D. Becoming Slav, Becoming Croat: Identity Transformations in Post-Roman and Early Medieval Dalmatia. Leiden; Boston, 2010.
Fees I. Eberardo marchese del Friuli // Dizionario biografico degli Italiani / Ed. A. Ghisalberti. Vol. 42: Dugoni – Enza. Roma, 1993. P. 252–255.
Goetz H.-W. Introduction // Regna and Gentes: The Relationship between Late Antique and Early Medieval Peoples and Kingdoms in the Transformation of the Roman World / Ed. by H.-W. Goetz, J. Jarnut and W. Pohl; with the Collaboration of S. Kaschke. Leiden; Boston, 2003. P. 1–12.
Howard-Johnston J. The De Administrando Imperio: A Re-examination of the Text and a Re-evaluation of its Evidence about the Rus // Les centres proto-urbains russes entre Scandinavie, Byzance et Orient. Actes du Colloque International tenu au Collège de France en octobre 1997 / Ed. par M. Kazanski, A. Nercessian, C. Zuckermann. P., 2001. P. 301–336.
Jenkins R.J.H. General Introduction // Constantine Porphyrogenitus. De Administrando Imperio. Vol. II: Commentary / Ed. by R.J.H. Jenkins with Contributions by F. Dvornik, R.J.H. Jenkins, B. Lewis, Gy. Moravcsik, D. Obolensky, S. Runciman. L., 1962. P. 1–8.
Komatina P. O hronologiji hrvatskih vladara u 31. glavi spisa De administrando imperio // RZHP. 2010. Knj. 42. S. 83–105.
Lončar M. Porfirogenetova seoba Hrvata pred sudom novije literature // Diadora. 1992. Sv. 14. S. 375–448.
Lončar M. Vremenski nesklad između odlomaka 31. poglavlja De administrando imperio // RZHP. 2010. Knj. 42. S. 107–116.
Majnarić I. Aemulatio imperii and the South-Eastern Frontier of the Carolingian World // Imperial Spheres and the Adriatic. Byzantium, the Carolingians and the Treaty of Aachen (812) / Ed. by M. Ančić, J. Shepard, and T. Vedriš. L., 2017. P. 43–56.
Margetić L. Bilješke uz Trpimirovu ispravu (CD I, 3–8) // Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Splitu. 1993. God. 30. Br. 1. S. 47–51.
Margetić L. Bilješke u vezi s nastankom hrvatske države u 9. stoljeću // Etnogeneza Hrvata / Ur. N. Budak. Zagreb, 1995. S. 144–147.
Markotić V. Ho ton Hrobaton Theos, Porphyrogenitus’ God of the Croats // Mandićev zbornik. U čast o. dra Dominika Mandića prigodom njegove 75-godišnjice života. Rome, 1965. P. 11–37.
Matijević Sokol M. 1150. obljetnica darovnice kneza Trpimira // 100 godina Arheološkog muzeja Istre u Puli: nova istraživanja u Hrvatskoj (Znanstveni skup, Pula, 8.–12. listopada 2002) / Odgovorni ur. D. Komšo. Zagreb, 2010. (Izdanja Hrvatskog arheološkog društva; 25). S. 8–18.
Milošević A. Tko je Porin iz 30. glave De administrando imperio? // SHP. Ser. III. 2013. Sv. 40. S. 127–134.
Rapanić Ž. Solinska epizoda europske povijesti // Vjesnik za arheologiju i historiju dalmatinsku. 1992. Sv. 85. S. 91–116.
Reimitz H. History, Frankish Identity and the Framing of Western Ethnicity, 550–850. Cambridge, 2015.
Sakač S.K. Ugovor pape Agatona i Hrvata proti navalnom ratu (oko god. 679) // Croatia Sacra. 1931. Vol. I. S. 1–84.
Shchavelev A.S. Treatise De Administrando Imperio by Emperor Constantine VII Porphyrogenitus: Date of the Paris. gr. 2009 Copy, Years of Compiling of the Original Codex, and a Hypothesis about the Number of Authors // Studia Ceranea. 2019. Vol. 9. P. 681–704.
Šišić F. Genealoški prilozi о hrvatskoj narodnoj dinastiji // Vjesnik Arheološkog muzeja u Zagrebu. 1914. Sv. 13. Br. 1. S. 1–93.
Vansina J. Oral Tradition as History. Madison, 1985.
Vedriš T. Razgovor ugodni: Konstantin VII Porfirogenet i percepcije najranije hrvatske povijesti // RZHP. 2010. Knj. 42. S. 13–36.
Vedriš T. Novi pogled na Čedadski evangelijar kao izvor za hrvatsku povijest devetog stoljeća // Magistra famosa. Zbornik u čast Mirjani Matijević Sokol / Ur. I. Botica, T. Galović, D. Karbić, S. Simon, F. Šimetin Šegvić, N. Šimetin Šegvić, M. Trogrlić. Split, 2023. S. 167–210.
Werner K.F. Völker und Regna // Beiträge zur mittelalterlichen Reichs- und Nationsbildung in Deutschland und Frankreich / Hrsg. von C. Brühl und B. Schneidmüller. München, 1997. (Historische Zeitschrift. Beihefte Neue Folge; 24). S. 15–44.
Živković T. De Conversione Croatorum et Serborum: A Lost Source. Belgrade, 2012. (a)
Živković T. Nova tumačenja vesti o južnoslovenskim gentes u De administrando imperio vizantijskog cara Konstantina VII Porfirogenita (944–959) // GCBI ANU BiH. Sarajevo, 2012. Knj. 41. S. 201–210. (b)